Parable of Money Systems

This entry is part 12 of 31 in the series 2011B

The bankers, politicians and deceived public have made a mockery out of our economic system by distorting and corrupting it. Many believe the problem is fiat money – that all money should be backed up with gold or some other commodity.

We have examined the gold systems of the past and numerous alternatives and have discovered they all have flaws.

Fiat money itself is not the great evil just as Don’s cherries were not a problem. The problem was Don was deceived into going needlessly into debt to purchase something that he already owned.

Even so, fiat money is not the problem as much as the fact that we purchase it rather than create it ourselves.

Here’s a parable that illustrates the positive side of fiat money when correctly created and used.

Parable of Money Systems

A master teacher called his 144,000 servants before him and spoke.

“I am dividing you into two groups and want each group to build a city for me. You are to start with nothing but your own wisdom and strength and the land that I will grant to you which shall be sufficient for your needs. By cooperating and working together you can build a beautiful city that will glorify the kingdom.”

“Each group will apply themselves a littler differently according to their own intelligence and in the end one will be more effective than the other. The results of the contrast between the two methods will teach us a valuable lesson.”

The teacher then directed them to the land they were to occupy and gave them some time to move their possessions thereon. After they were settled in and camped in tents they were instructed to begin.

For a few days nothing much happened for there was no leadership and each group of 72,000 had many contrasting ideas of how to proceed. Finally, both groups decided to elect leaders, for without leadership they seemed to be like ships adrift at sea with no rudder.

They spent the next few weeks electing leaders on several levels that gave the groups capacity to govern the whole. After this the presidents of both groups called their people together and gave similar messages:

“My Friends,” said one of them. “Our master teacher has given us a great assignment, but so far all we have done is gather, get settled in and elect leaders. Now is the time for action and we must proceed.”

“But how are we to proceed?” asked a member of the audience. “All we have is the bare necessities to survive let alone build a city.”

The President spoke, “Apparently our teacher thinks we have the ability to create the tools and gather all; the ingredients to build a city. Yes, it will take a lot of work and ingenuity, but I believe we can succeed and make our teacher proud. We must therefore divide into work groups and proceed with making tools and gathering the needed raw materials.”

Both groups created assignments of duty and proceeded, but after a short time the leaders became painfully aware that the work was proceeding very sluggishly. Both presidents sent consultants to investigate the problem and both received a similar report. Said one, “The people are complaining. Many are slow or reluctant to work because their fellow workers are not doing their share. Everybody is waiting for the other guy to work before he works.”

“The problem,” said the President, “Is the Teacher gave us no money to begin this project so we are left with working with natural motivation to get the job done.”

A consultant responded, “We’re finding out without pay the people will do very little for the group good. We need some type of money to pay them with. If we had money we could get them to work.”

The President rose up, walked back ands forth, and spoke, “If its money they need then its money they shall have. We will create a money system and pay the workers. Have the consultants draw up a plan.”

Up to this point the two groups proceeded similarly. However, the two groups of consultants came up with two plans for the creation of money which were very different.

The first group of consultants approached their President. “Sir, we believe that we cannot create real money out of thin air. It has to be backed up by something tangible such as a precious metal.”

“Suppose we had all the people deliver all their belongings to a central storehouse and we use these as backing for money,” said the President.

The head consultant spoke, “Taking what little they have would have to be done by force and even if we could do this their possessions are few and there is not enough to create the money we need.”

“What do you suggest then?” said the President.

“Even though we do not have the precious metals now we can get them. There is gold in the nearby hills that we can mine. As soon as we get a supply we can then issue money which is backed by a real tangible material – gold. We can mine the gold, store it in vaults and then issue money to pay for labor. We know the people will work for money so at that point the work can proceed as we direct.”

“It’s quite possible the other group will have this same idea. Is there enough gold for both of us?” asked the President.

“The area where the gold is located is only large enough to accommodate one group. If two of us go at it then we will be at each other’s throat,” said the consultant.

“Then we must secure the area immediately and claim it for ourselves,” said the President.

The first group then proceeded to lay a claim to the area wherein the gold was deposited, built a fence around it and set guards so only their group could have access. After this, most of the group began participating in mining for gold.

Around this time the second president called his consultants together and contemplated the same problem. When one of them proposed creating money backed by gold another answered, “Unfortunately, the other group has moved forward with this idea and has staked out a claim on the only gold in the area. The only way for us to obtain gold is to go to war with them.”

“That’s pout of the question,” said the President. “There must be another way. Are there more precious metals available to mine we could use?”

“None that we know of.”

“Is there any other way that we can create money then? Speak if any of you have ideas.”

“There is another way,” said another consultant. “We can create it out of thin air.”

“That sounds outrageous,” said the President. “Surely you can’t be serious.”

“I’m very serious,” said the consultant. “Actually the creation I am talking about is not really out of thin air at all, but it can seem that way to those who believe that the only real money is backed by a precious metal.”

“You’ve got my interest. Tell me your plan.”

The consultant moved forward and spoke, “My plan will not only create real usable money, but it will save us all kinds of useless time digging for gold and storing it. This will allow us the advantage of completing the city much faster than the other group.”

“I see your point,” said the president. “The other group is now spending all their time digging for gold and this shall continue for heaven knows how long. If we can avoid doing this then we shall have an advantage indeed. How do we proceed?”

“Here is how it works. We will issue money by fiat but it will have value unlike money printed up by some guy on his own in a basement.”

“How is that?” said the president.

“The fiat money will be backed by the people’s good faith in the government of our perspective city and each dollar will represent not gold, but labor. Each twenty dollar bill will represent an average of an hour’s labor.”

An average?” he asked.

“Yes. Some people without skill may only have their labor valued at $10 a hour while some with skills may be valued at $50 or more. By averaging the value I have calculated that the average value of an hour’s labor is about $20.

“So how do we distribute the money?”

“We just print up what we will need to keep people employed and enter the bills in circulation as needed to pay for their labor. Then as the money re-circulates we will need to introduce smaller amounts, but only what is needed to maintain a stable balance.”

“I see two possible problems,” said the President. “Something could happen to take the money out of circulation producing deflation or we could have unscrupulous people in the government print up too much money and we would have inflation where the dollar would lose its value.”

“But that’s a danger around the creation of money by any means,” said the consultant. “If the other group has their gold stolen or they print up too much money in relation to the gold supply then they face the same problem we do. In fact, other kingdoms have had this problem with money related to gold since paper notes have existed.”

“The only way to make sure our money remains stable is responsible oversight. There is no other way with any paper currency.”

“I see your point,” said the President. “I also see another advantage that may have escaped you.”

“What’s that?”

“If there was a large gold discovery or if our alchemists solved the problem of transmuting lead into gold then the value of the other group’s money would plunge and their society could be destroyed.”

“Yes, that is a possibility,” said the consultant.

“But the value of an hour’s labor is always worth an hour’s labor and our dollar can remain steady as long as the money supply is wisely measured.”

“That is correct,” said the consultant.

“Then let us proceed,” said the President. “We will dispense with the wasted time of mining for gold and immediately begin work on gathering materials for the city.”

The second group then explained the program to its citizens and paid the workers in fiat money as they commenced labor. Within a short period of time the whole community was bristling with activity and the foundations to the city began.

When the first group saw that the second group had already laid the foundations to the city while they were still mining for gold they became alarmed. This alarm reached the President and his consultants.

“What is this?” said the first President. “The other group has reached full employment and has not only gathered raw materials but is laying the foundation to their city. All this has been accomplished while we are still mining for enough gold to create sufficient backing to employ the kingdom.”

A consultant stepped forward and explained, “There’s nothing to worry about. We have done some research and discovered the second group is not using real money. They are using fiat money which is just manufactured out of thin air.”

“What do you mean thin air? How does thin air get the jump on us in creating full employment and building a city?”

“They are cheating, sir and their cheating will soon catch up with them. Because their money is not based on gold or any tangible commodity it will only be a matter of time before their system collapses completely. Then we can offer then some of our gold, buy up all their materials and be the first to complete the city.”

“Are you sure about this?” asked the President. “It looks like the people are convinced they are getting real money and as long as they are convinced they will keep building the city.”

“But they are fooled by a deceptive government and bankers,” said the consultant. “We shall expose them and the day will soon come that their house of cards will come tumbling down.”

Both groups then proceeded with their various philosophies on money. It took a year of struggle and sacrifice before the first group mined sufficient gold to create a viable money system but even after this they had to keep a portion of their people mining for gold to keep new gold infused into the system. These people who mined the gold were unable to perform any labor that contributed to the building of the city.

Two years passed and several times it looked like both money systems would fail. It turned out there was criminal negligence on both sides but the leadership of both governments were upright enough to catch their mistakes and correct them.

Each time the second group had any problem with their money the first group relaxed their labors thinking there would soon be a collapse and they would soon own the materials of both cities. But it turned out that both the fiat and the gold backed money had the same problems and both required honest government to insure that the people could prosper.

Another year passed and the second group had completed a beautiful city with housing for all the inhabitants. The city of the first group was only half done and many homes lay unfinished.

At this time the teacher called the leaders of both groups to appear before him.

“I see that one group has completed a beautiful city and the other has not. Tell me what has made the difference here?”

The President of the first group stepped forward and explained. “Sir, the second group has cheated. They paid their group with funny money created from nothing. We created our money from gold stored in vaults and it will retain its value while the economy of the other group will soon come crashing down and then we will buy the whole city for pennies on the dollar.”

“But I see before me a beautiful city,” said the teacher. “Such beauty is not created from nothing. Perhaps the other president can explain.”

The second President stepped forward and explained. “You are right sir, this city was not created from nothing. We issued money that was backed by the good faith of the people in their own labor. Labor may not be visible as is gold, but it is not nothing. As proof look and see what our money backed by labor has produced.”

“I understand you had a culprit that printed up some extra money for selfish ends,” said the teacher.

“Yes,” said the second President, “but so did the other group. We both had some problems because of it and we both made corrections.”

“I see,” said the teacher. “So you both had viable money systems and honest government. How do you explain the fact that you finished your city so much faster than the gold standard group?”

The second President answered, “Because gold in a vault by itself does not produce anything, but takes away many productive labor hours to mine and refine. We took all those hours and spent them building the ingredients of a city that adds joy to the lives of the inhabitants. Gold in a vault by itself accomplishes nothing.”

The first President then became very angry and exclaimed, “My teacher, you do not understand. We have the only viable money system. This other money system is based upon lies. Just wait another year or so and their system will completely collapse and we shall buy up the whole thing. Then we shall own both cites.”

The teacher contemplated and responded, “My friend, do you not see the wisdom of the second group who are relying on the value of labor rather than visible objects?”

“But sir, their money is fiat money built upon nothing!”

The teacher thought again and responded, “Then perhaps I must teach you where the real value of money lies.” He then took an ancient scroll from a table and handed it to the second President. “Here is the formula for transmuting lower elements into higher ones. With this you can make all the gold, silver and other metals you wish. You can pave the streets of your city with gold if you wish.”

The first President spoke again, his voice quaking, “If he makes enough gold to pave his streets then there will be so much gold our money will become useless and the effort we have made will come to an end. Please don’t do this to us.”

“I am not hurting you. You are hurting yourself,” said the teacher. “I am also giving you the opportunity to pave your streets with gold. All you have to do is learn your lesson that labor will always have value, a value that will outlast gold or any other commodity. Have faith in the labor of your brothers and you shall prosper and pave your streets with gold, otherwise your people will rebel against you and your fate shall be a terrible thing.”

After thinking long and hard the first President swallowed his pride and sought to change his money system to be based in the faith of the labor of his brethren. It was not long before the cities were completed and both had streets of gold that sparkled in the sun.

Read This entire series. Here are the links.

Copyright 2011 by J J Dewey

Copyright by J J Dewey

Index for Older Archives in the Process of Updating

Index for Recent Posts

Easy Access to All the Writings

Register at Freeread Here

Log on to Freeread Here

For Free Book go HERE and other books HERE

JJ’s Amazon page HERE

Gather with JJ on Facebook HERE

Series NavigationGiving Away Our PowerTo Fiat or Not Fiat

4 thoughts on “Parable of Money Systems

  1. Blayne, commenting on the parable:
    Interesting that it relies on the fantasy of transmuting led into gold to make gold and silver look bad and exclaims that creating an abundance of gold through transmutation will make it worthless.

    JJ
    The parable does not rely on the transmutation creating an abundance of gold. The main point would have been made even if I left that off and the main point is this.

    The time spent mining for gold and then placing it in a vault where it just sits there could be much better spend in creating something that can be used by the people.

    Blayne
    When in fact it is fiat money through out history that has had that very problem because of over abundance due to ease of printing.

    JJ
    Any standard of money can be mismanaged but there have been a number of times in history where fiat money has been quite successful. I’ll be writing about them shortly.

    Blayne
    I see no reason why the folks who wanted gold and silver backed currency would not barter and trade, plant gardens and fields, build their homes etc instead of just waiting around doing nothing while waiting for enough gold to be mined to create a monetary system so they can be paid for their labors. It makes no sense

    JJ
    They would have done some of that but without the incentive of money or some type of payment their work would have been limited.

    Without money they would have had to work in a communist styled program and we both know how inefficient that is with our current state of consciousness.

    Blayne:
    The whole thing seems very unrealistic to me and leaves out way too many elements of what constitutes society. People would be motivated to build their homes plant crops, raise livestock, create goods and services etc so they could eat and trade since those are all valuable commodities and help each other in trade for their varying skills and commodities.

    JJ
    This would have happened to a degree but not as fast as if they were paid in money to do the work that was not the fun stuff. Also they wouldn’t have had much time for that because they would have been very busy mining for gold so they could start up a money system.

    Blayne:
    In time gold and silver would become a valuable trading commodity and no need for a central government controlled monetary system period.

    JJ
    And when has this ever happened in the past? The Constitution gives the government power over money creation and value because the founders realized that this was one of the true functions of government.

    Blayne:
    The free market would settle on what was the preferred medium of trade. Pretty much how most towns and cities were created in America in the 18th and 19th centuries and around the world in different eras.

    JJ
    That’s not the way it was in the 18th and 19th centuries. The central government set the value of gold as being equal to 15 and then 16 the value of silver and the silver dollar was set by the government to be equal to the average weight of the Spanish dollar. Without the government setting value and standards who knows what type of chaos we would have had with money.

    Blayne:
    Of course the people that gathered would have brought some of their currencies and commodities with them unlike the parable where they were just plopped down out of nowhere in the middle of nowhere with next to nothing.

    JJ
    But what if we had to start fresh like Adam and Eve? I’ve started with nothing several times in my life myself. Starting with nothing is the ultimate test to discover the true basis of wealth.

    Even today those who would gather may not have many material things of value. Those who already have abundance are much more reluctant to start fresh.

    Blayne;
    The point seems to be that fiat currency is better then gold and silver or precious metals backed currencies, if so then it fails to make the point in my opinion. It touts labor as the reason fiat currency has value when the term fiat currency means it is not tied to anything.

    JJ
    I think if you could move forward in time you would see that fiat money will dominate and be much more stable as banking systems are set up that favor the people rather than the bankers. Then eventually money will disappear when the desire for service becomes enough to create wealth.
    Fiat currency is not created from nothing. If this were so you and I could create currency of similar power and we cannot. Why?

    Because any currency you or I could create would not be backed by the people who are willing to labor to maintain its value. No one is willing to labor for money I create but they are happy to for Uncle Sam’s endorsed fiat money.

    Blayne
    I have yet to see a viable system of labor backed currency.

    JJ
    All the money of the world is backed by labor. The moment that people would stop laboring for money would be the moment it would be worthless.

    Blayne:
    it would be interesting to see a model of how to value the labor like ditch digger vs doctor or farmer etc.

    JJ
    We do that now. We pay the ditch digger one thing and the doctor another for their different types of labor.

    Blayne;
    Traditionally labor has been valued by what it produces and that commodity or service sold or traded to compensate for ones labor.

    JJ
    Of course.

    Blayne:
    The parable really relies on central control by some governmental body to keep corruption from happening which has never been accomplished in history since every fiat currency in history has ended badly so I would not put any faith in such and system.

    JJ
    Every money system in history and every government has eventually failed. These two things live in cycles. We are approaching a new cycle. Does this mean we should not make the best of this new era while it lasts and make it better than the last one?

    No.

    Even though the best we can put together will be in danger of corruption at some point that doesn’t mean we cannot take joy in the abundant life while it lasts.
    It doesn’t matter whether we use gold, silver, labor or pure faith for money for we will be at the mercy of human nature to a degree. We will be wise to create a system that takes human weakness into account and gives people power to set authorities in order when necessary.

    Blayne
    Sorry to be the wet blanket however that is how I see it.

    JJ
    No problem. If I make any mistakes on this subject I want to know about them before I publish my book.

  2. Interesting that it relies on the fantasy of transmuting led into gold to make gold and silver look bad and exclaims that creating an abundance of gold through transmutation will make it worthless. When in fact it is fiat money through out history that has had that very problem because of over abundance due to ease of printing. I see no reason why the folks who wanted gold and silver backed currency would not barter and trade, plant gardens and fields, build thier homes etc instead of just waiting around doing nothing while waiting for enough gold to be mined to create a monetary system so they can be paid for thier labors. It makes no sense

    The whole thing seems very unrealistic to me and leaves out way to many elements of what constitutes society. People would be motivated to build thier homes plant crops, raise livestock, create goods and services etc so they could eat and trade since those are all valuable commodities and help each other in trade for their varying skills and commodities. In time gold and silver would become a valuable trading commodity and no need for a central government controlled monetary system period. The free market would settle on what was the preferred medium of trade . Pretty much how most towns and cities were created in America in the 18th and 19th centuries and around the world in different eras. Of course the people that gathered would have brought some of thier currencies and commodities with them unlike the parable where they were just plopped down out of nowhere in the middle of nowhere with next to nothing.

    The point seems to be that fiat currency is better then gold and silver or precious metals backed currencies, if so then it fails to make the point in my opinion. It touts labor as the reason fiat currency has value when the term fiat currency means it is not tied to anything. I have yet to see a viable system of labor backed currency. it would be interesting to see a model of how to value the labor like ditch digger vs doctor or farmer etc. Traditionally labor has been valued by what it produces and that commodity or service sold or traded to compensate for ones labor.

    The parable really relies on central control by some governmental body to keep corruption from happening which has never been accomplished in history since every fiat currency in history has ended badly so I would not put any faith in such and system. Maybe some day when we are all more enlightened but not anytime soon.

    Sorry to be the wet blanket however that is how I see it.

  3. “My friend, do you not see the wisdom of the second group who are relying on the value of labor rather than visible objects?”

    One could also say that the wisdom is in relying also on the value of God rather than visible objects to worship.

    Ruth

  4. I have liked this parable from the first reading of it a few years ago. It has taken all that time or little time depending on your perspective to learn that my labor and working honestly with my fellow man has true lasting value and has enriched my life in so many ways. Even when I have offered my service with no compensation, I received compensation in ways I could never have imagined.

    Matthew

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

code